America Needs a New National Security Act


Screen Shot 2018-01-29 at 9.30.13 PM.png

Congress passed the National Security Act of 1947 in response to the rise of Communism and the Soviet Union’s growing global threat. In general, the postwar legislation is credited with having created our modern national security apparatus. The Department of Defense, the Central Intelligence Agency, and the National Security Council all came to exist to ameliorate the problems that the United States experienced in the early days of fighting World War II, when a lack of coordination and disjointed efforts sometimes hampered our war plans.

In order to prevent that kind of problem from recurring during the Cold War (and to better manage the complex requirements of national defense in the nuclear age), the National Security Act put the National Security Council at the heart of this new national defense system. It was designed to be the mechanism through which all of the various agencies involved in national security met and disseminated their institution’s views on a given problem the country was facing.

The national security adviser would then iron out the problems they faced—and analyze the various opinions proffered by the intelligence, military, and diplomatic communities—so that he might then advise the president. This was known in bureaucratese as the “interagency process.” And, when the interagency process works well, the country is made safer while the president can manage global problems that threaten Americans more easily.

Over the years, the interagency process has become increasingly mismanaged and far too complex. Plus, in the post-Cold War era, organizations not traditionally involved in the national security policy-making realm—such as the Department of Commerce—have become critical players in this arena. Given the changing nature of our threats, sometimes this involvement is legitimate. In other instances, however, it is as dubious as the Environmental Protection Agency’s involvement in national security discussions because of “anthropogenic climate change,” and its alleged threat to national security.

Of course, the more one dilutes true foreign and national security policy, the more unmanageable that process becomes—and the more likely it is that mistakes will be made.

Take for example, the Iraq War of 2003. That was as much a failure of the interagency process as it was anything else. While Condoleezza Rice is certainly a bright and patriotic woman, she was ill-suited for the role of national security adviser—especially when having to contend with the titans of the first term George W. Bush Administration foreign policy team—Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, Vice President Dick Cheney, Secretary of State Colin Powell, and even CIA Director George Tenet.

Each one of these men had their own agendas, alliances, and ability to access the president. Further, all of them worked simultaneously to mollify the national security adviser, in order to push their cherry-picked version of the facts in Iraq. Had a more seasoned, skilled, and respected person managed the national security process (Rumsfeld is rumored to have once famously referred to Rice as a “glorified Russian Studies graduate student”), things might have turned out differently for the George W. Bush administration in Iraq.

Fact is, since the original National Security Act of 1947 was passed, the world—and the requirements for national security—have changed immeasurably. Meanwhile, our most important institutions for national defense have only gotten larger (but not necessarily better at defending the country). They’ve become pigs—led by bureaucratic sheep—in a world of wolves. And pigs get slaughtered.

Please click over to American Greatness to finish reading. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s